Mini Key Lime Pie

This website may contain affiliate links and advertising so that we can provide recipes to you. Read my privacy policy.

Since visiting The Keys on our cruise, I have been CRAVING key lime pie. Since being home I have been searching for a good recipe that would cure my craving for it. Since I like things in mini individual sizes, I thought that I would create them just like my mini cheesecakes. I was shocked at how delicious and close these tasted to the key lime pie in Florida. They were amazing! They were perfectly moist and had the perfect amount of lime in them. I took them over to my parents for dinner and they couldn’t even wait to eat them. My hubby isn’t even a huge fan of key lime pie and loved it! It was so fun being able to remember all of the fun memories we made in the Keys with one delicious bite!

Two mini key lime pies on a white plate and garnished with a sliver of lime and a dollop of whipped cream on top.

Rating: 4 stars  Difficulty of Recipe: 3 stars
Review:  Loved everything about this recipe and it is surprisingly easy. The only thing that I would change is the graham cracker and better ratio. I misread the original recipe and put in ¾ cup butter instead of ¾ stick of butter! Oops! Although still amazing I will definitely be reducing the amount next time I make them! 🙂


Mini Key Lime Pie

No ratings yet
They were amazing! They were perfectly moist and had the perfect amount of lime in them.
Prep Time 15 minutes
Cook Time 12 minutes
Total Time 27 minutes
Author Alyssa Rivers
Servings: 12 Pies


  • 1 1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs crushed (about 12 squares)
  • 3 Tablespoon Sugar
  • 3/4 stick butter about ⅓ cup
  • 3 large egg whites beaten
  • 2 cans sweetened condensed milk 14 oz.
  • 3/4 cup lime juice
  • 1 T Lime zest
  • 1/3 cup nonfat greek yogurt


  • Crush the graham cracker squares in a food processor or place in a gallon size bag and roll with a rolling pin.
  • Add sugar and butter and mix into the crushed graham cracker.
  • Press 1 tablespoon graham cracker mixture into the bottom of a cupcake liner. I put 1 T in and then pressed down with ¼ cup measuring cup. You have the option to bake this at 350 degrees for 8 minutes so that it can harden. I skipped this part and it turned out great!
  • In a separate bowl, mix together egg whites, condensed milk, lime juice, lime zest, and greek yogurt. Mix well.
  • Fill the cupcakes about ¾ of the way full with the mixture. Bake for 12-15 minutes and cool.
  • Top with whip cream and garnish with lime if desired. Store in the refrigerator.


Serves: 12

Calories280kcal (14%)Carbohydrates48g (16%)Protein7g (14%)Fat7g (11%)Saturated Fat4g (20%)Cholesterol23mg (8%)Sodium168mg (7%)Potassium301mg (9%)Fiber1g (4%)Sugar42g (47%)Vitamin A184IU (4%)Vitamin C6mg (7%)Calcium204mg (20%)Iron1mg (6%)

All nutritional information is based on third party calculations and is only an estimate. Each recipe and nutritional value will vary depending on the brands you use, measuring methods and portion sizes per household.

Course Dessert
Cuisine American
Keyword key lime pie, pie recipes
Tried this recipe?Mention @alyssa_therecipecritic or tag #therecipecritic
The famous Key Lime Pie Factory!
You might also enjoy:
Stay up to date with The Recipe Critic!

Facebook | Pinterest | Twitter | Google +

Alyssa Rivers

I am Alyssa and the blogger behind The Recipe Critic. I started my blog in June of 2012 as a place to share my passion for cooking. I love trying new things and testing them out with my family.

Read More Posts by Alyssa

facebook twitter pinterest instagram



Leave a reply
  1. Awsome! I love a great key lime pie/cheesecake, too. Please post again if you tweak it to 5 stars. I’ve just discovered your blog and am excited to poke around!

  2. Hi Alyssa!! How did I not know you had this awesome blog!! Wow…so I just got done pinning so many yummy looking recipes for me to try!! I plan on pinning MANY more!! 🙂

  3. That does sound like quite a bit of butter. I am always surprised at how little butter you really need in crusts. We have been to the Keys twice and have been to that key lime shop both times. Love it!!!

  4. How cute are these little pies? They look AMAZING. I can’t wait to visit the Keys one day so I can try their authentic pie, but until then, this will do the trick 🙂

  5. OH. MY. WORD. These look delicious! Definitely going on my Sunday dinner menu! New follower stopping by and love your blog. I’m also friends with Jeni from Isn’t she a cutie? Deb @

  6. Hey, I just checked the original recipe that you linked to, and it calls for 3/4 stick of butter, not 3/4 cup! That would make it 6 T or just over 1/3 cup. 🙂 I just thought you’d like to know! These look great- I’m going to make them today!

  7. Hi there! I found this recipe on PINTEREST!!! (Yes I’m addicted! but it brought me here! ha) I made this just now and used ground Nilla waffers instead of gram. crackers…! Sweetened it up a little more I think added just enough vanilla flavor! I also didn’t have a real lime so I used concentrated lime juice little nore than 1/4 cup. YUMMMOOOOO!!! Thanks so much for sharing!!!

  8. These are delicious! I’ve made key lime pie before, but never thought to bake it in muffin cups to make them cute and tiny. I was surprised that they peeled out of the muffin cups so easily once they were cool, but they did! Thanks for the fun idea!

    Just a few notes for others who want to make these: I found that I needed 18 graham cracker squares (9 full crackers) to get 1 1/2 cups of crumbs. I was able to make 18 little pies, using 1 tbsp of crumbs and filling the cups pretty full. Personally, I would have liked a little more crust, but it worked out well so that I didn’t have any leftover filling.

  9. I just discovered you on Pinterest – the mini Key lime pie recipe. Can’t wait to make it.

    I noticed in the recipe that you didn’t specify Key lime juice – just lime juice. I think it should be – there’s a world of difference. Also, sorry, the teacher in me saw 2 typos – stick of butter reads stuck of butter, and also in the instructions – separate as in “separate bowl” is misspelled.

    Also, I went to print the recipe, and it would be nice if it had a Print friendly button. Darker print would be nice as well.

    Sorry – just trying to make it better! Thanks!

    1. Haha maybe I should hire you to edit my recipes! 😉 I just get typing so much I miss all of that. Thanks for noticing! And I just switched to wordpress so I am in the process of switching all of my recipes to a card and making them printable. I will try to do this one as soon as I can! Let me know how it turns out! This is one of our favorites!

  10. Hi there,
    If I were to cook these in mini muffin tins how long would you cook them? Do you keep in the fridge until serving?

    1. Hmmm good question. I’m not too sure on that one but they wouldn’t take long to cook. Maybe 5-7 minutes. 🙂

  11. Hi I just come across to this yummy pie from Facebook, and brought me to your blog. I definitely will made this. But do have question, from the original recipe it said 3 egg yolks but here it said egg white. If using egg white, what is the “beaten” level? Thanks

    1. Yes I used egg whites instead. Unbeaten. I am sure it would still be great using egg yolks but I wanted mine to be white. 🙂

  12. So I’ve come across your post for these adorable mini key lime pies about a month ago and have needed a reason to make them. FINALLY, I have. My boyfriend and I are going to a picnic his family is holding and I decided it was the perfect time. They came out beautifully, delicious creamy a little bit of a tart finish. The only thing I added was I put lime zest in the grahm cracker crust. Also, I did not bake the crust on the first batch, and decided to on the rest, which i do recommend for about 4-6 minutes. Either way I’m very excited to see what everyone thinks. And of course my favorite part is there not only delicious but very cute!

  13. I just made these for my key-lime-loving boyfriend and he absolutely loved em! I was able to make 24 of these babies. I did 2T white sugar and 1T brown sugar for the crust and it came out amazing!

  14. Hey! This recipe is amazing! We made it in my foods II class. Does anyone know how many calories are in one mini pie?? email me thanks!!

  15. I wanted to like this blog so much. I really did. But there were so many problems with this recipe. Spelling, clarifications, etc. such a shame. Maybe hire an editor?

    1. Are you kidding me? Is this comment for real? Wow. Some people. I am a mom. I started my blog to share recipes that our family has enjoyed. I am not perfect and I am also not rich. I am a regular person just like everyone else.

      1. Tell ’em Alyssa! Yes ’em…she…she..all ‘o them! We real people appreciate your time, talent and energy. Please delete that comment. t’s gvng m a tmmy che;)

      2. Alyssa, just ignore these people. I found your blog and am so scared of baking/cooking. You should hear my lemon herb chicken story….recipe never told me to cut the lemon then rub all over the chicken so dumb me I just took a whole lemon and rubbed and rubbed and rubbed….blandest chicken ever! You’ve given me hope and confidence.

  16. These sound SO YUMMY!! 1 question, do you melt the butter before mixing with graham cracker crumbs? I always have in other recipes, just wanted to make sure!! Can’t wait to try these!! Thanks for sharing!!

  17. Maybe I did something wrong, but my graham crust was extremely greasy (maybe too much butter)…and my fillng fell after the mini pies cooled. Does anyone have any suggestions on where I may have gone wrong.

  18. Is the butter supposed to be melted or softened? I looked through a few comments before I asked. Thanks!

  19. I made these earlier today and they came out great! As a previous comment suggested, I used about 18 graham cracker squares (or 9 full sheets). Thanks for a great recipe!

  20. I looked at the original recipe you linked just to see the difference between them, and I noticed that the original calls for 3 egg yolks where yours calls for 3 egg whites. I was just wondering the reason and how egg yolks as opposed to egg whites would change the outcome. Thanks. Looking forward to making these.

  21. Hello 🙂 I’m thinking of trying this recipe out but tripling it. Anything tips before I get started? Also, is it possible to use less of the condensed milk? Thanks!

  22. Hi there-

    Do you use a regular sized or mini-cupcake pan for this? When you wrote that you use the bottom of a 1/4 cup to press down, it made me think it is just regular sized. Just wanted to clarify. I think I will make these for a party I am hosting this weekend!

  23. Did you use key limes or regular limes? I have always been told that the 2 were not interchangeable in a recipe like this. I would live a good lime recipe for the 2 dozen limes I have and this sounds wonderful.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating